The Problem of Evil
|The situation: a broken-hearted father mourning the loss
of his only son. The image is striking and the pain he feels reaches for
our hearts. We raise our hands in despair and question the existence of
God in the face of an evil that is relentless, universal and utterly
real. How do we as Christians answer the problem of evil when our Faith
professes that God exists and He is love?
St. Thomas Aquinas meets the objection head on and answers the problem with his usual razor-sharp efficiency:
That's the intellectual answer. Now for the practical one.
Respondeo dicendum quod
There are no easy answers. In fact, the problem of reconciling the existence of evil with an all-powerful, omnipotent good God is extremely daunting. It's not impossible, but the answer might not be wholly comforting to a father who lost his only son in a chain of events that seem awfully meaningless. It is emotionally gut-wrenching, and intellectual answers like the one St. Thomas provided may seem too antiseptic, even though it is absolutely reasonable. The argument that answers the problem of evil must be given flesh and blood and not just remain as a intellectual proposition on a page.
The Christian faith does just this, which is why I personally find Christianity to be most the satisfying option available. The reconciliation between the existence of an omnipotent God of goodness and the existence of evil, pain and suffering is found in the Cross. There, we find a story -- a true one -- which is the ultimate realization of the horror that the aforementioned father encounters in the seemingly meaningless death of his only son.
In the eyes of history, it seems like the biggest mistake, the worst practical joke, a meaningless mess of a would-be Messiah whose life ended in a death that even our "advanced" civilization wouldn't subject to a dog.
On the other hand, to the eyes of faith, the Cross was paradoxically the most meaningful act in all of human history. Here was God's sharing into the human condition, a partaking of the loss for a most precious love that a father could ever have.
Paradoxically, in the Cross, evil was answered by justice and mercy, which may seem irreconcilable to our understanding. However, in the act that saw the death of Christ, the barrier between justice and mercy was broken and its fruits were given to humanity as the ultimate answer to the problem of evil. The answer to this problem is not a mere intellectual exercise, but was given a human face -- and that is the face of Jesus Christ.
Thus, the answer given by St. Thomas comes full circle: omnipotent Goodness Himself found a way to produce goodness outweighing the evil in which it was taken from. This Goodness gave the answer to the problem of evil for humanity by becoming one of us and suffering through an evil that summarizes the pain of all humanity, including that of the father today who feels the loss of an only son.
The good news of the Cross is that the death that evil brings was too
weak to keep Life incarnate in the grave, but Jesus who is Life burst
forth in the Resurrection, which proves that God exists, God is Love and
Love is stronger than death.
Kreeft, Peter and Ronald K. Tacelli, SJ. Handbook of Christian Apologetics. Downers Grove [IL]: Intervarsity Press, 1994.
see also Solutions
to the Problem of Evil by Norman Geisler and others
For us and our salvation,
Back to Apologetics Articles
Back to Home Page
About | Apologetics | Philosophy | Spirituality | Books | Audio | Links